What the councils' own study reveals

An independent study commissioned by Lancashire County Council, working with Fylde, Wyre and Blackpool Councils, found a cheaper route for the Morgan and Morecambe wind farm cables, with a fraction of the digging. It was sent to the Prime Minister and the Energy Secretary. The government approved the original route anyway.

On 14 September 2026, the government gave consent for the Morgan and Morecambe wind farm cables to come ashore at Starr Gate and run underground across the Fylde to Penwortham. For residents and farmers along the route, that means years of disruption.

It did not have to be this way.

The government's route

The approved route lands at Starr Gate beach, next to Blackpool Airport. From there, an underground cable corridor of around 25 to 35 kilometres runs across the Fylde to the National Grid at Penwortham.

The corridor is typically 70 to 80 metres wide. Up to 18 underground cables could be laid in it. Two new substations are planned in the area around Kirkham, Newton and Freckleton.

Much of it runs through Green Belt and working farmland.

The alternative: Rossall to Hillhouse

The study, carried out by Genecon with independent engineers Blake Clough and Pell Frischmann, looked at a northern route instead.

The cables would come ashore at Rossall, run around 5 kilometres, mostly along existing roads, to the Hillhouse Technology Enterprise Zone at Thornton, and connect into the overhead power lines that already run from Stanah to Penwortham.

That is around 5 kilometres of underground cable instead of 30. It keeps the cables off Fylde farmland.

The engineers found no engineering barrier to landing the cables at Rossall.

Hundreds of millions cheaper

The developers never published the cost of the approved route, so the engineers worked out their own estimate. They put it at around £443 million.

The northern route came in at between £156 million and £193 million. That is a saving of between £250 million and £287 million.

If the planned Isle of Man wind farm, Mooir Vannin, were connected the same way, the saving rises to more than half a billion pounds.

These are costs that end up on energy bills.

Jobs for the coast

Hillhouse is the former ICI site. It gained Enterprise Zone status in 2016, but in ten years it has added just 76 jobs.

The study found a new substation there could finally unlock the site.

It estimated:

  • Around 1,100 additional jobs at Hillhouse.
  • Between £99 million and £177 million a year for the local economy.
  • Between £1 billion and £1.77 billion over the decade to 2040.

By contrast, the study found the approved route offers "little to no economic benefit" to the Fylde Coast.

Sent to the top, then ignored

The study was sent to the Prime Minister, the Energy Secretary and other ministers.

The planning inspectors who examined the scheme recommended that consent be refused, mainly because of the harm to the Green Belt.

The government overruled them. On the question of alternative routes, it said national policy did not require it to consider them.

Residents are entitled to ask why a cheaper option, backed by independent engineers and four local councils, was not even looked at.

How we got here

This did not start with Labour.

The Conservatives wrote net zero into law in 2019. In 2022, under a Conservative government, the national grid plan chose Penwortham as the connection point for these wind farms and set the cables on course across the Fylde.

Labour have carried it on and signed it off.

The party in charge has changed. The approach has not.

What the study does not hide

The study is open about what the northern route would involve. The existing overhead lines would need upgrading, and a new development consent would be needed. The cost of the upgrades is included in the figures above.

Even with those included, the northern route still came out hundreds of millions of pounds cheaper.

A wind farm without a developer

There is another problem. In January 2026, the developer behind Morgan, the larger of the two wind farms, pulled out after failing to secure government support. The project was no longer financially viable.

A route costing hundreds of millions less could have helped make it viable again. That point was ignored too.

The legal challenge

Fylde Council has decided not to pursue a judicial review.

Newton-with-Clifton Parish Council has now submitted a legal claim against the decision, backed by TASC. A judge will decide whether it goes to a hearing.

Reform Fylde thanks FACTS for working alongside us on this.

County Councillor Joshua Roberts, Cabinet Member for Rural Affairs, Environment and Communities at Lancashire County Council, said:

"We put forward a route that was cheaper, needed far less digging and kept the cables off our farmland. We sent it to the Prime Minister and the Energy Secretary. It was ignored. The government's own inspectors said refuse, and ministers overruled them. Westminster decides and Fylde pays. I will keep pushing for the northern route wherever there is still a chance to change things."

Reform Fylde calls for answers

We are asking the government to answer the following:

  1. Why was the independent study not considered before the decision was made?
  2. Why did ministers overrule their own planning inspectors, who recommended refusal?
  3. Will the government publish its own cost estimate for the approved route?
  4. With Morgan's original developer gone, will the route be reviewed before the site is re-tendered?
  5. Will Stanah be properly considered as the connection point for the Isle of Man wind farm?

The people of Fylde deserve a straight answer.

Westminster decides. Fylde pays. It should not be that way.