What Fylde Council's own documents reveal

Reform Fylde has examined internal Fylde Council meeting minutes and Freedom of Information responses concerning the £1.6 million St Annes Pier Link improvement scheme. The documents raise significant questions about costs, workmanship, procurement and transparency.

The Pier Link project was intended to improve the connection between St Annes Promenade and the town centre. However, what was supposed to be an improvement scheme has become the subject of growing questions over delays, rising costs and the quality of the finished work.

Having obtained internal council documents, Reform Fylde has identified several issues that residents deserve answers to.

The £200,000 budget increase

The original Pier Link budget was approximately £1.397 million. This subsequently increased to around £1.597 million – an increase of approximately £200,000.

Fylde Council's own board minutes confirm that the project was proceeding on the basis of this increased allocation.

The minutes also record that the contractor's initial pricing exercise prompted a review of the budget, following revised assumptions about the extent of carriageway construction.

With £1.6 million of public money involved, residents are entitled to understand exactly how the additional expenditure was justified and whether the project represents value for money.

No standalone feasibility study?

Through a Freedom of Information request, Reform Fylde specifically asked for the feasibility studies, options appraisals and business case prepared for the Pier Link project.

Fylde Council confirmed that it does not hold a standalone feasibility study, options appraisal or business case specifically for Pier Link.

It also confirmed that it holds no separate recorded assessment comparing the different surfacing options for the scheme.

However, there is an apparent discrepancy. The council's budget documentation refers to a business case being submitted to Lancashire County Council in January 2025.

Reform Fylde has requested clarification from Fylde Council to establish what documentation was prepared and where it is held.

The resurfacing problem: the entire surface needs replacing

Perhaps the most concerning finding relates to the quality of the road surface.

Council communications had previously referred to defects in certain areas.

However, internal meeting minutes dated September 2026 record that several defects were identified during final quality inspections.

These included:

  • Poor level control.
  • Uneven binder course.
  • Over-chipping and under-chipping.
  • Ponding.
  • Plucking of the surface material.

The minutes specifically record that Lancashire County Council's Highways team inspected the road alongside the project team and contractor George Cox.

Their agreed conclusion was that the best course of action was to remove the entire surface course and relay it.

This is not simply a case of filling a few potholes or repairing isolated patches. The entire surface course needs to be replaced.

The council has stated that the remedial resurfacing will be undertaken at no additional cost to it. That is welcome, but questions remain about how the work was allowed to reach this stage.

Why the tarmac instead of the paving?

Residents have also questioned the appearance of the finished scheme, particularly where sections have been completed in black asphalt rather than matching paving.

The council's minutes record discussions about changing the surfacing arrangements. However, the contractor warned that this could substantially increase costs and cause further delays.

The decision was therefore made to retain black asphalt rather than pay for a grey finish.

Given that the council has confirmed it holds no separate recorded assessment comparing the surfacing options specifically for this project, questions remain about how these decisions were evaluated.

Questions over contractor arrangements

The documents also raise questions about the contractor arrangements.

George Cox had previously undertaken work on the St Annes Square project. Minutes from July 2025 record concerns about quality which resulted in a new paving subcontractor being appointed.

Further minutes from September 2025 record a decision not to pursue backdated delay damages against the contractor, with the existing relationship and goodwill cited.

The Pier Link contract was subsequently awarded to George Cox without a full tender exercise.

This does not, in itself, establish that procurement rules were breached. However, residents are entitled to understand the reasoning behind the appointment and what assurances were obtained regarding price, quality and delivery.

Were residents being given the full picture?

The internal minutes also contain some interesting entries concerning public communications.

Minutes from June record an action for communications to focus on achievements, completed areas and reopened footways rather than delays to the programme.

Separately, September minutes record that a council representative suggested it would be beneficial for George Cox to view a proposed public announcement about a delay before publication.

The minutes also record that the council intended to contact the contractor to highlight the urgency of issuing the update.

These entries raise legitimate questions about how information was communicated to residents and the extent to which public updates reflected the difficulties facing the project.

A wider picture for St Annes

Pier Link cannot be considered entirely in isolation.

Residents are already facing the loss of local facilities, including the closure of St Annes swimming baths and the paddling pool. Meanwhile, concerns remain over the condition of the boating lake and its reported water leakage.

Against that backdrop, residents understandably expect public investment to be properly planned, delivered and managed.

Improving St Annes is something residents should welcome. But investment must deliver what was promised, represent value for money and be subject to proper scrutiny.

Reform Fylde calls for answers
  1. Why did the Pier Link budget increase by approximately £200,000?
  2. Where is the business case referred to in the council's budget documentation?
  3. What assessments were undertaken to establish the best-value surfacing options?
  4. How did the road surface pass through construction before defects were identified at final inspection?
  5. What was the justification for awarding the contract without a full tender exercise?
  6. What assurances are in place to ensure the remedial works are completed to the required standard?

The council has confirmed that the defective resurfacing will be corrected at no additional cost to it. We welcome that commitment.

However, that does not remove the need for accountability over the decisions that led to this situation.

It is your money. You deserve transparency, proper scrutiny and value for money.

Reform Fylde will continue to seek answers on behalf of residents.